Station.com
Sign In Join Free Why Join?
Sony Online Entertainment
Community Store My Account Help
  Search   |   Recent Topics   |   Member Listing   |   Back to home page
Algorithm: Black - Feedback
Search inside this topic:
The Matrix Online » Top » Community » Player Events Previous Topic  |  Next Topic      Go to Page: Previous  1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5  Next
Author Message


Vindicator

Joined: Aug 1, 2006
Messages: 3144
Location: New Zealand
Offline

Thanks for the feedback Ballak, that's the kind of thoughtful input that is most useful to planners of future events. 



Vindicator

Joined: Oct 22, 2005
Messages: 8296
Location: Ye Olde Hole Ine The Tree
Offline

Ballak wrote:

Well, the fact that there are people who were willing to give the people from this PE disclosed information is sort of disturbing. To promote that on the internet is sort of riskae, and it's not something I'd want this AB to be doing to me. Even the out of game interactions is a little over the line. Sure, they're probably people you know just under a different alias trying to improve the gameplay in our little game.


I personally enjoyed the phone call. Maybe you're just antisocial.

Really, though, I've seen my share of blunders, like the excessive advertising on other websites and forums. A mystery should be spread mysteriously, not thrown about with big neon signs.



Systemic Anomaly

Joined: Aug 24, 2005
Messages: 3182
Location: Megacity, USA
Offline

Ballak wrote:

The idea of Algorithm Black is a little over-used. It seems they are starting to become sort of intertwined with Scanline, which is something I really would advise against. If this is strictly a player event, then in the LESIG/LE world they do not exist. They will not be recognized as part of the storyline just as 700-year-old lesbian vampires are easily thrown aside by the Matrix-storyline bible that Rarebit holds so dear.

Not entirely true. Some player stories do in fact get recognized by LESIG and Rarebit himself, it's just that they're rare. Now, from the information that I have seen, Algorithm: Black didn't mention Scanline until the Sentinel came out around the start date. Scanline was mentioning The Algorithm a bit before that. So if Scanline has mentioned The Algorithm, then I'd say that qualifies as being recognized, wouldn't you?

Ballak wrote:

Trying to solve the puzzle through various bits and pieces of information while weeding out the useless things = So-So. Some of the stories are interesting, others just simply are not.

Part of the fun of non-linear gaming is trying to figure out what is useful and what isn't while following up on several leads. The technique is called a red herring.




Systemic Anomaly

Joined: Sep 8, 2005
Messages: 2388
Location: Neverwhere
Offline

Ballak wrote:
naes177 wrote:
Because LESIG events are so much better and well-conceived?  Lollerskates.


You would know, amirite?

I never said Algorithm: Black is bad, just certain parts of it I don't agree with. It's good, people like it. Don't get rid of it. Some of the things they do are questionable, but there really isn't that much of a majority against it. You even said yourself you think it's one of the best player events since the beginning and that's fine.

Yes, I would know.

~V



Vindicator

Joined: Aug 21, 2006
Messages: 3158
Location: ALL YOUR AVATARS ARE BELONG TO ME
Offline

Foxxdie wrote:
Ballak wrote:
naes177 wrote:
Because LESIG events are so much better and well-conceived?  Lollerskates.


You would know, amirite?

I never said Algorithm: Black is bad, just certain parts of it I don't agree with. It's good, people like it. Don't get rid of it. Some of the things they do are questionable, but there really isn't that much of a majority against it. You even said yourself you think it's one of the best player events since the beginning and that's fine.

I would know, and yeah it is, by far.

Criticism is always nice and I've offered mine, but it just sounds like you are pissy because you can't/don't want to solve puzzles. Ok, fine, continue about your business.


I'm not that very good at puzzles. I was just pointing out that it doesn't make it easier when everyone's got their own little bit to add to the puzzle when it really isn't necessary which is annoying, but I guess sometimes there really isn't anything to solve and you're just doing it for your own enjoyment. That aside though, I guess I was wishing for more of a Joker-type event where everyone was more or less OOC (IC ingame) trying to solve the puzzle. As for the LESIG/PE relationship, I really don't see that big of a difference between this and the Joker events; long, interactive puzzles that grasps most of the community's attention. Just because it was LESIG instead of PE doesn't change the theme. You also have to realize Algorithm Black was sort of at the "meh" popularity level for a lot of people until they just started naming out people and giving out garbled/mysterious soundbits and pictures. When people get attention, they get involved, so that boosted them up. They have Raijinn supporting it, so more and more just keep getting on the bandwagon. What's wrong with that? Nothing. This event is a great idea, it's just I question some of their motives.

I'm sorry if I made you feel that I hate the event because of my own disability.

-Zippy: Well, I guess for me there's a fine line between Real Life and this game. I don't really want people from MxO giving me phone calls or whatever. MxO is almost like a second identity for me, just something I do when I'm bored and I usually have a lot of time to be bored. You enjoyed it, that's your opinion. It could possibly be paranoia, but I'm rather cautious when handing out information to anonymous people, even if they're part of this knit-pick community.

Archangel wrote:

Ballak wrote:

The idea of Algorithm Black is a little over-used. It seems they are starting to become sort of intertwined with Scanline, which is something I really would advise against. If this is strictly a player event, then in the LESIG/LE world they do not exist. They will not be recognized as part of the storyline just as 700-year-old lesbian vampires are easily thrown aside by the Matrix-storyline bible that Rarebit holds so dear.

Not entirely true. Some player stories do in fact get recognized by LESIG and Rarebit himself, it's just that they're rare. Now, from the information that I have seen, Algorithm: Black didn't mention Scanline until the Sentinel came out around the start date. Scanline was mentioning The Algorithm a bit before that. So if Scanline has mentioned The Algorithm, then I'd say that qualifies as being recognized, wouldn't you?

Ballak wrote:

Trying to solve the puzzle through various bits and pieces of information while weeding out the useless things = So-So. Some of the stories are interesting, others just simply are not.

Part of the fun of non-linear gaming is trying to figure out what is useful and what isn't while following up on several leads. The technique is called a red herring.

For the first thing, technically, or at least according to Rarebit, anything made by the player isn't considered part of the matrix universe, like how every player is an operative. No, you may think your an exile/vampire/program/agent, but you're really not. Technical-RP-wise, we're all from the fields after the Truce was broken, shipped to Zion where we did our first missions there. So really, every Algorithm operative you see has gone through that same process, etc. etc. I'm sure they'd be recognized as an organization or faction, but they will never have an effect on the storyline. If so, this blatantly isn't a player event. So this whole, A:B trying to renew the peace thing is obviously not going to happen unless the peace is renewed by some other means. If they try to take credit for it, then that would be distasteful.

The red herring, although as you're explaining it to me is obviously a technique that I would not discourage A:B from doing, it's actually the players doing it. And even then it really isn't the Red Herring part, but it's having to read through conversations with the player's character and their operator or who ever.

Which, I apologize again if I made it sound like that was A:B's fault, because that's out of their control. I meant it in more of a general over-view of the event so far. It's out of their hands, so why should I blame them?


Message edited by Ballak on 11/06/2007 15:28:52.



Systemic Anomaly

Joined: Sep 8, 2005
Messages: 2388
Location: Neverwhere
Offline

Ballak wrote:
Foxxdie wrote:
Ballak wrote:
naes177 wrote:
Because LESIG events are so much better and well-conceived?  Lollerskates.


You would know, amirite?

I never said Algorithm: Black is bad, just certain parts of it I don't agree with. It's good, people like it. Don't get rid of it. Some of the things they do are questionable, but there really isn't that much of a majority against it. You even said yourself you think it's one of the best player events since the beginning and that's fine.

I would know, and yeah it is, by far.

Criticism is always nice and I've offered mine, but it just sounds like you are pissy because you can't/don't want to solve puzzles. Ok, fine, continue about your business.


I'm not that very good at puzzles. I was just pointing out that it doesn't make it easier when everyone's got their own little bit to add to the puzzle when it really isn't necessary which is annoying, but I guess sometimes there really isn't anything to solve and you're just doing it for your own enjoyment. That aside though, I guess I was wishing for more of a Joker-type event where everyone was more or less OOC (IC ingame) trying to solve the puzzle. As for the LESIG/PE relationship, I really don't see that big of a difference between this and the Joker events; long, interactive puzzles that grasps most of the community's attention. Just because it was LESIG instead of PE doesn't change the theme. You also have to realize Algorithm Black was sort of at the "meh" popularity level for a lot of people until they just started naming out people and giving out garbled/mysterious soundbits and pictures. When people get attention, they get involved, so that boosted them up. They have Raijinn supporting it, so more and more just keep getting on the bandwagon. What's wrong with that? Nothing. This event is a great idea, it's just I question some of their motives.

I'm sorry if I made you feel that I hate the event because of my own disability.

-Zippy: Well, I guess for me there's a fine line between Real Life and this game. I don't really want people from MxO giving me phone calls or whatever. MxO is almost like a second identity for me, just something I do when I'm bored and I usually have a lot of time to be bored. You enjoyed it, that's your opinion. It could possibly be paranoia, but I'm rather cautious when handing out information to anonymous people, even if they're part of this knit-pick community.

So you're basically saying you didn't think it was a good event because you couldn't figure things out and/or didn't enjoy what you did manage to figure out?

Concise criticisms.

~V



Vindicator

Joined: Aug 21, 2006
Messages: 3158
Location: ALL YOUR AVATARS ARE BELONG TO ME
Offline

naes177 wrote:
Ballak wrote:
Foxxdie wrote:
Ballak wrote:
naes177 wrote:
Because LESIG events are so much better and well-conceived?  Lollerskates.


You would know, amirite?

I never said Algorithm: Black is bad, just certain parts of it I don't agree with. It's good, people like it. Don't get rid of it. Some of the things they do are questionable, but there really isn't that much of a majority against it. You even said yourself you think it's one of the best player events since the beginning and that's fine.

I would know, and yeah it is, by far.

Criticism is always nice and I've offered mine, but it just sounds like you are pissy because you can't/don't want to solve puzzles. Ok, fine, continue about your business.


I'm not that very good at puzzles. I was just pointing out that it doesn't make it easier when everyone's got their own little bit to add to the puzzle when it really isn't necessary which is annoying, but I guess sometimes there really isn't anything to solve and you're just doing it for your own enjoyment. That aside though, I guess I was wishing for more of a Joker-type event where everyone was more or less OOC (IC ingame) trying to solve the puzzle. As for the LESIG/PE relationship, I really don't see that big of a difference between this and the Joker events; long, interactive puzzles that grasps most of the community's attention. Just because it was LESIG instead of PE doesn't change the theme. You also have to realize Algorithm Black was sort of at the "meh" popularity level for a lot of people until they just started naming out people and giving out garbled/mysterious soundbits and pictures. When people get attention, they get involved, so that boosted them up. They have Raijinn supporting it, so more and more just keep getting on the bandwagon. What's wrong with that? Nothing. This event is a great idea, it's just I question some of their motives.

I'm sorry if I made you feel that I hate the event because of my own disability.

-Zippy: Well, I guess for me there's a fine line between Real Life and this game. I don't really want people from MxO giving me phone calls or whatever. MxO is almost like a second identity for me, just something I do when I'm bored and I usually have a lot of time to be bored. You enjoyed it, that's your opinion. It could possibly be paranoia, but I'm rather cautious when handing out information to anonymous people, even if they're part of this knit-pick community.

So you're basically saying you didn't think it was a good event because you couldn't figure things out and/or didn't enjoy what you did manage to figure out?

Concise criticisms.

~V

No, I'm saying it'd be easier to solve the *CENSORED* thing if I didn't have to go through everyone's RP *CENSORED* that doesn't appeal to me in the first place.

But it's not like I have any control over that, right? So yeah, it's annoying. I also added to my previous post that enlightened more to that, but unfortunately you can't quote things twice without having to opening up a new window etc. IE for the lose.

I guess we are not entitled to an opinion though, Vanil. Or at least, if it's not a positive one.


Message edited by Ballak on 11/06/2007 15:44:51.



Virulent Mind

Joined: Mar 6, 2006
Messages: 110
Offline

(Great idea for the thread, constructive criticism is always important, its one of the best ways we can all learn from mistakes, although sometimes it is hard to separate personal feelings from the equation and look at something for what it is as a whole)

touch on a few points brought up-

Firstly dealing with the private information, a few simple steps that could of been included to alleviate fears would be simple add that in additional information not required, if people are really wanting to take the event outside the game then great they can enter there information and presto they can be included, if not then they simple don't enter the information, with identity theft and people wanting to keep Ingame and out of game separate that is totally understandable. (Also a disclaimer should of also been added in first off)

Like the excessive advertising on other websites and forums. A mystery should be spread mysteriously, not thrown about with big neon signs.

A good example there Zippy, and yes it does remove some of the mystery surrounding events, people can be gently nudged along a path if need be but there is no need to slam them in the face with a big ------> this way sign. People are quite smart and resourceful and  can usually find what they need to find.

Dealing with other peoples RP well thats a character to character issue and something totally out of any event organizers hands, we see it at live events all the time something that you cant really stop, whether you like it or not.

As for the LESIG/PE relationship, I really don't see that big of a difference between this and the Joker events; long, interactive puzzles that grasps most of the community's attention.

I think the main difference between the two has been accessibility, to me the joker event catered more for a select few, and yes i had issues solving the puzzles much like you were saying about the AB puzzles Ballak, but hell someone obviously got it as we can see by how far the Joker event went, which is obviously good. The most impossible task for any event coordinater LESIG or PE or Rarebit is to make a line between to easy and to hard, there will always be people complaining so again a no win situation.

As for what is recognized and what isnt by Rarebit, Chadwick or LESIG, does this matter in the grand scheme of things, players will recognize what they want, what they find interesting and what compels them to stay. It has become blatantly obvious that we have to invent our own fun around here and more power to anyone that can capture the imagination of the MxO community.

In summary the event has its flaws yes, every event does, look at the main story line and the plot holes you can drive a truck through. Does it matter if you are having fun and are compelled to look further to stay and to enjoy the ride .....personally i dont think so.

Additional: As far as i understand the event goes until the end of November, by my count we are only in the first week, i for one am going to enjoy the ride for as long as it lasts, will there be problems yeah for sure, but unless there is a sudden influx of lesbian vampires or a army of Neo clones i can overlook them and just enjoy it for what is is, a bunch of guys trying to give us something to entertain and make remember what the Matrix was all about...intrigue







Message edited by Cihesh on 11/06/2007 16:32:52.



Ascendent Logic

Joined: Oct 31, 2005
Messages: 696
Offline

Well as far as with everyone's personal information, the only thing I saw they were asking for was email (I think that's for the obvious) cell phone number or home number and if I'm not mistaken the state where you live in. If memory serves, the information was voluntary and if you didn't give it out it wouldn't keep you out of the event or the AB forums for that matter. I understand that they asked this information to add an element into the rp and that was it. So as far as motive for the information being other than for the event well I'm sorry Ballak but I just don't see it.

As far as the puzzles being a little confusing due to the rp, well all I can say is that with almost every event I have been involved with it takes a few tries before you grow comfortable with the character your assigned (by the way, I am not with the AB team) but then after a while the role becomes more comfortable and the rp that much more believable. I know i certainly wouldn't want a character from an event to just tell me blandly to "go to warehouse B, there is a meeting , here's the coords, be there at 3pm ....bye"

Canon or not canon..well yes Rarebit can say "absolutely not , this doesn't exist in the Matrix universe" and that would pretty much be it as far as what is canon. However when I think of hordes of zombies coming out the wood work to ten foot Yeti's for Christmas, it kind of plausible that the AB event to be taken with some believability (and yes I know the Halloween and Christmas events are for fun).

I don't think it's a question of everyone jumping on the bandwagon and mindlessly cheering the event on just because it has gained popularity, but I do believe that it has brought some life into this game. Otherwise all we would have had for Halloween is a pumpkin grab, some new masks oh and the "Ugliest RSI"contest" *rolls eyes*

And Ballak I don't want you to think I am criticizing you for you opinion, because some good points were brought out.



Vindicator

Joined: Aug 21, 2006
Messages: 3158
Location: ALL YOUR AVATARS ARE BELONG TO ME
Offline

Yes you both bring up good points, and I admit my arguement/complaint is sort of bsed in some things as it was most scornfully pointed out by some of the posters here. I appreciate you not criticizing me on my opinion. The only thing I wish to say is that for them to contact you in real life, although you willingly give up the information, is just a little, I don't know, strange. It's for the event, of course, but you don't know who you gave those numbers to, and what about after the event? It's not like the information will be obsolete.

phi


Systemic Anomaly

Joined: Aug 18, 2005
Messages: 3393
Location: [SERVER]Recursion [FACTION]Kings of Never [REAL]Systems Administrator
Offline

Ballak wrote:
Yes you both bring up good points, and I admit my arguement/complaint is sort of bsed in some things as it was most scornfully pointed out by some of the posters here. I appreciate you not criticizing me on my opinion. The only thing I wish to say is that for them to contact you in real life, although you willingly give up the information, is just a little, I don't know, strange. It's for the event, of course, but you don't know who you gave those numbers to, and what about after the event? It's not like the information will be obsolete.

http://www.algorithmblack.com/forum....php?topic=58.0

Meow

Disclaimer

All data other than screenname, password, and email is voluntary. If you do provide us with the optional data, it will be used for event purposes only. Your information will not be distributed to any third parties. Access to this data is restricted to event organizers only. For security reasons, the data is stored in a separate system, and will be deleted when the event is over.

Thank you for your support.

-The Algorithm: Black Team.


Message edited by phi on 11/06/2007 17:09:08.



Ascendent Logic

Joined: Mar 21, 2006
Messages: 1901
Offline

I think it's great that a group of people are willing to invest time and come up with something like this for MxO.

On a side note I'm upset that my sig was changed... that darn Algorithm *shifty* SMILEY



Clairvoyant

Joined: Jun 10, 2007
Messages: 251
Location: Men's Room, Mara Central Church
Offline

Jurymen wrote:
I think it's great that a group of people are willing to invest time and come up with something like this for MxO.

On a side note I'm upset that my sig was changed... that darn Algorithm *shifty* SMILEY
Dun-dun-duuuuuuuuuun!





Vindicator

Joined: Aug 20, 2005
Messages: 3065
Location: Upstate NY
Offline

I just want everyone to know that this whole thing has been a sham; an elaborate plan for these "people" to recruit you to their side for the real purpose of getting rid of ManBearPig.

You have all been fooled by the AlGore-ithm.

You'll never get me! /shakefist


odj


Vindicator

Joined: Oct 5, 2006
Messages: 2254
Location: UK - Wales
Offline

Vesuveus wrote:

I just want everyone to know that this whole thing has been a sham; an elaborate plan for these "people" to recruit you to their side for the real purpose of getting rid of ManBearPig.

You have all been fooled by the AlGore-ithm.

You'll never get me! /shakefist

Hahaha I loled. SMILEY

 
The Matrix Online » Top » Community » Player Events Go to Page: Previous  1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5  Next
Go to:   

Version 2.2.7.43