Station.com
Sign In Join Free Why Join?
Sony Online Entertainment
Community Store My Account Help
  Search   |   Recent Topics   |   Member Listing   |   Back to home page
Punch Reversal Catch Slam
Search inside this topic:
The Matrix Online » Top » Development Discussion » Development Roundtable Previous Topic  |  Next Topic      Go to Page: Previous  1 , 2 , 3 , 4  Next
Author Message


Systemic Anomaly

Joined: Feb 12, 2006
Messages: 2406
Location: Western Australia
Offline

Confuse stops you from even changing tactics (Speed, power, grab, block) and give you a CT downgrade. Stun stops you from using special moves and also give you a CT downgrade.



Vindicator

Joined: Aug 21, 2006
Messages: 3158
Location: ALL YOUR AVATARS ARE BELONG TO ME
Offline

Pylat wrote:
Confuse stops you from even changing tactics (Speed, power, grab, block) and give you a CT downgrade. Stun stops you from using special moves and also give you a CT downgrade.


After a quick test-run. You're right, you get a -20 CT bonus from Stun (which in IL only affects your normal interlock rounds), but I couldn't find anything regarding Confuse besides the switch tactics. It's in essence, from what I could tell, a powerless that doesn't allow you to switch tactics, which honestly from the intentions of the game's combat system really shouldn't let you switch tactics anyways because "technically" that's an exploit that somehow is accepted because it's used so often.

Even so, that doesn't change the fact that these happen less than half the time (30% on Suicidal, and unknown for the Wrist Throw, but still not 100% as we know it), as opposed to the 100% PRCS. Wrist Throw has 31 DPS with a 65 IS cost, Suicidal with a 35 IS cost and 25 DPS, and PRCS totalling in at 21 DPS and a 40 IS cost. The only thing that seems a little off is the huge jump of IS cost with Wrist Throw, with Kung Fu having Average, Karate having Above Average, and Aikido having Below Average damage which is normal in the differences for the trees. PRCS also has the highest Interlock Accuracy boost of all three of them, at 20 compared to WT 18, and SBF 7 (lol). It just amazes me how this move has a 100% chance to powerless as opposed to the lower percentages (SBF being 30% which is very low compared the 70% increase of PRCS) of the others.

It just doesn't seem like to me the huge increase in percentage is compensating for one round in which you can't tactic switch or you might possibly lose due to a negative CT debuff (not like you'd be doing any abilities to tactic switch anyways, unless you're just sitting on block which wouldn't matter or grab, which again wouldn't matter. I actually don't see why you'd want to change especially for MA when it's just grabpowergrabpower with the ability spam. It's rare for people to go for states once they've gone past the initial going into interlock round.).


Message edited by Ballak on 06/14/2008 22:57:03.



Jacked Out

Joined: Aug 29, 2005
Messages: 2122
Location: BG
Offline

Ballak wrote:
Pylat wrote:
Confuse stops you from even changing tactics (Speed, power, grab, block) and give you a CT downgrade. Stun stops you from using special moves and also give you a CT downgrade.


After a quick test-run. You're right, you get a -20 CT bonus from Stun (which in IL only affects your normal interlock rounds), but I couldn't find anything regarding Confuse besides the switch tactics. It's in essence, from what I could tell, a powerless that doesn't allow you to switch tactics, which honestly from the intentions of the game's combat system really shouldn't let you switch tactics anyways because "technically" that's an exploit that somehow is accepted because it's used so often.

Even so, that doesn't change the fact that these happen less than half the time (30% on Suicidal, and unknown for the Wrist Throw, but still not 100% as we know it), as opposed to the 100% PRCS. Wrist Throw has 31 DPS with a 65 IS cost, Suicidal with a 35 IS cost and 25 DPS, and PRCS totalling in at 21 DPS and a 40 IS cost. The only thing that seems a little off is the huge jump of IS cost with Wrist Throw, with Kung Fu having Average, Karate having Above Average, and Aikido having Below Average damage which is normal in the differences for the trees. PRCS also has the highest Interlock Accuracy boost of all three of them, at 20 compared to WT 18, and SBF 7 (lol). It just amazes me how this move has a 100% chance to powerless as opposed to the lower percentages (SBF being 30% which is very low compared the 70% increase of PRCS) of the others.

It just doesn't seem like to me the huge increase in percentage is compensating for one round in which you can't tactic switch or you might possibly lose due to a negative CT debuff (not like you'd be doing any abilities to tactic switch anyways, unless you're just sitting on block which wouldn't matter or grab, which again wouldn't matter. I actually don't see why you'd want to change especially for MA when it's just grabpowergrabpower with the ability spam. It's rare for people to go for states once they've gone past the initial going into interlock round.).

Comparing it yeah it seems Wrist throw and PRCS should be rebalanced. However that last comment is completely inaccurate for good MAs, which is why syntax has the worst MAs.


Vindicator

Joined: Aug 21, 2006
Messages: 3158
Location: ALL YOUR AVATARS ARE BELONG TO ME
Offline

The Leo wrote:
Ballak wrote:
Pylat wrote:
Confuse stops you from even changing tactics (Speed, power, grab, block) and give you a CT downgrade. Stun stops you from using special moves and also give you a CT downgrade.


After a quick test-run. You're right, you get a -20 CT bonus from Stun (which in IL only affects your normal interlock rounds), but I couldn't find anything regarding Confuse besides the switch tactics. It's in essence, from what I could tell, a powerless that doesn't allow you to switch tactics, which honestly from the intentions of the game's combat system really shouldn't let you switch tactics anyways because "technically" that's an exploit that somehow is accepted because it's used so often.

Even so, that doesn't change the fact that these happen less than half the time (30% on Suicidal, and unknown for the Wrist Throw, but still not 100% as we know it), as opposed to the 100% PRCS. Wrist Throw has 31 DPS with a 65 IS cost, Suicidal with a 35 IS cost and 25 DPS, and PRCS totalling in at 21 DPS and a 40 IS cost. The only thing that seems a little off is the huge jump of IS cost with Wrist Throw, with Kung Fu having Average, Karate having Above Average, and Aikido having Below Average damage which is normal in the differences for the trees. PRCS also has the highest Interlock Accuracy boost of all three of them, at 20 compared to WT 18, and SBF 7 (lol). It just amazes me how this move has a 100% chance to powerless as opposed to the lower percentages (SBF being 30% which is very low compared the 70% increase of PRCS) of the others.

It just doesn't seem like to me the huge increase in percentage is compensating for one round in which you can't tactic switch or you might possibly lose due to a negative CT debuff (not like you'd be doing any abilities to tactic switch anyways, unless you're just sitting on block which wouldn't matter or grab, which again wouldn't matter. I actually don't see why you'd want to change especially for MA when it's just grabpowergrabpower with the ability spam. It's rare for people to go for states once they've gone past the initial going into interlock round.).

Comparing it yeah it seems Wrist throw and PRCS should be rebalanced. However that last comment is completely inaccurate for good MAs, which is why syntax has the worst MAs.
Syntax has the worst MAs, yet really there is no way to compare the difference between Recursion or Vector to Syntax, so technically although you may find that true to yourself, that's just your personal opinion from a tournament rarely anybody shows up to anymore probably because they don't care about being the best MA ever, imo (no offense). At least on Syntax.



Jacked Out

Joined: Aug 29, 2005
Messages: 2122
Location: BG
Offline

Ballak wrote:
The Leo wrote:
Ballak wrote:
Pylat wrote:
Confuse stops you from even changing tactics (Speed, power, grab, block) and give you a CT downgrade. Stun stops you from using special moves and also give you a CT downgrade.


After a quick test-run. You're right, you get a -20 CT bonus from Stun (which in IL only affects your normal interlock rounds), but I couldn't find anything regarding Confuse besides the switch tactics. It's in essence, from what I could tell, a powerless that doesn't allow you to switch tactics, which honestly from the intentions of the game's combat system really shouldn't let you switch tactics anyways because "technically" that's an exploit that somehow is accepted because it's used so often.

Even so, that doesn't change the fact that these happen less than half the time (30% on Suicidal, and unknown for the Wrist Throw, but still not 100% as we know it), as opposed to the 100% PRCS. Wrist Throw has 31 DPS with a 65 IS cost, Suicidal with a 35 IS cost and 25 DPS, and PRCS totalling in at 21 DPS and a 40 IS cost. The only thing that seems a little off is the huge jump of IS cost with Wrist Throw, with Kung Fu having Average, Karate having Above Average, and Aikido having Below Average damage which is normal in the differences for the trees. PRCS also has the highest Interlock Accuracy boost of all three of them, at 20 compared to WT 18, and SBF 7 (lol). It just amazes me how this move has a 100% chance to powerless as opposed to the lower percentages (SBF being 30% which is very low compared the 70% increase of PRCS) of the others.

It just doesn't seem like to me the huge increase in percentage is compensating for one round in which you can't tactic switch or you might possibly lose due to a negative CT debuff (not like you'd be doing any abilities to tactic switch anyways, unless you're just sitting on block which wouldn't matter or grab, which again wouldn't matter. I actually don't see why you'd want to change especially for MA when it's just grabpowergrabpower with the ability spam. It's rare for people to go for states once they've gone past the initial going into interlock round.).

Comparing it yeah it seems Wrist throw and PRCS should be rebalanced. However that last comment is completely inaccurate for good MAs, which is why syntax has the worst MAs.
Syntax has the worst MAs, yet really there is no way to compare the difference between Recursion or Vector to Syntax, so technically although you may find that true to yourself, that's just your personal opinion from a tournament rarely anybody shows up to anymore probably because they don't care about being the best MA ever, imo (no offense). At least on Syntax.
That's an oppinion of 10 people I know, and the purpose of the tourneys was to see which server had best players.

Anyhow since after 5 threads about rebalancing wrist throw and yet no effect I doubt this will happen either (too tired of talking to the wall, so don't really care anymore).


Vindicator

Joined: Aug 21, 2006
Messages: 3158
Location: ALL YOUR AVATARS ARE BELONG TO ME
Offline

The Leo wrote:
Ballak wrote:
The Leo wrote:
Ballak wrote:
Pylat wrote:
Confuse stops you from even changing tactics (Speed, power, grab, block) and give you a CT downgrade. Stun stops you from using special moves and also give you a CT downgrade.


After a quick test-run. You're right, you get a -20 CT bonus from Stun (which in IL only affects your normal interlock rounds), but I couldn't find anything regarding Confuse besides the switch tactics. It's in essence, from what I could tell, a powerless that doesn't allow you to switch tactics, which honestly from the intentions of the game's combat system really shouldn't let you switch tactics anyways because "technically" that's an exploit that somehow is accepted because it's used so often.

Even so, that doesn't change the fact that these happen less than half the time (30% on Suicidal, and unknown for the Wrist Throw, but still not 100% as we know it), as opposed to the 100% PRCS. Wrist Throw has 31 DPS with a 65 IS cost, Suicidal with a 35 IS cost and 25 DPS, and PRCS totalling in at 21 DPS and a 40 IS cost. The only thing that seems a little off is the huge jump of IS cost with Wrist Throw, with Kung Fu having Average, Karate having Above Average, and Aikido having Below Average damage which is normal in the differences for the trees. PRCS also has the highest Interlock Accuracy boost of all three of them, at 20 compared to WT 18, and SBF 7 (lol). It just amazes me how this move has a 100% chance to powerless as opposed to the lower percentages (SBF being 30% which is very low compared the 70% increase of PRCS) of the others.

It just doesn't seem like to me the huge increase in percentage is compensating for one round in which you can't tactic switch or you might possibly lose due to a negative CT debuff (not like you'd be doing any abilities to tactic switch anyways, unless you're just sitting on block which wouldn't matter or grab, which again wouldn't matter. I actually don't see why you'd want to change especially for MA when it's just grabpowergrabpower with the ability spam. It's rare for people to go for states once they've gone past the initial going into interlock round.).

Comparing it yeah it seems Wrist throw and PRCS should be rebalanced. However that last comment is completely inaccurate for good MAs, which is why syntax has the worst MAs.
Syntax has the worst MAs, yet really there is no way to compare the difference between Recursion or Vector to Syntax, so technically although you may find that true to yourself, that's just your personal opinion from a tournament rarely anybody shows up to anymore probably because they don't care about being the best MA ever, imo (no offense). At least on Syntax.
That's an oppinion of 10 people I know, and the purpose of the tourneys was to see which server had best players.

Anyhow since after 5 threads about rebalancing wrist throw and yet no effect I doubt this will happen either (too tired of talking to the wall, so don't really care anymore).
I could go in a long rant about how those tournaments do exactly opposite of that, but since this thread isn't about Hidden or his tournament, we'll just leave it at that, 'k?



Femme Fatale

Joined: Oct 27, 2007
Messages: 1223
Offline

Pylat wrote:
I see people use Freedom to Joints rather often when fighting hackers actually. PRCS is not a god mode attack, if it was so God like (As you imply) every MA would be spamming it all over the place, yet they aren't.
As a hacker with a fair amount of PvP time under her belt I have to say I've seen the exact opposite of what Pylat says here.  No one ever uses FtJ against me but certain MAs like to constantly shut me down with PRCS.  It's not insurmountable, but 100% does seem somewhat too much.  I wouldn't advise dropping it to 40 or 50 as Ballak suggested but 70% should be about right. 



Jacked Out

Joined: Aug 27, 2005
Messages: 357
Location: Syntax: AlphaCoder Vector-Hostile: GuardianAngel
Offline

I can see what you are getting at Ballak, but the reason I see for the 100% powerless is because of the defensive nature of the aikido tree. The damage is low, comparatively,  and the powerless is short, as a user of aikido I would support a slightly longer re-use timer for it, but apart from that I see no other problem, as it has been said, aikido is made up predominantly of state requiring moves, so when in IL the 2 helpful moves until you state your opponent are maki-otoshi (only if you are against another MA) and PRCS, then you rely mostly on the other MA tree or just regular IL rounds depending on your LO. However if you check the trees, most of the good, non-state MA specials are on the same side as PRCS, eg; EFK, therefore if you spam EFK you aren't getting off any really decent MA specials, and, again, given the defensive nature of aikido I don't think it's a very useful tactic.

To answer your comment/slightly rhetorical q about Freedom to Joints, it's never used by any decent mkt/assassin in IL because the animation is SO *CENSORED* LONG, by the time you have pulled it off you have had 3 DoT's, a knife, and a crippling shot on you, otherwise I think it would be used more.

FAR is a different story, but it really needs to be restricted to IL only, people are talking from the perspective of out of IL, if you are in IL and have someone shooting you with power tactic waiting for the staggered, they are more likely to state you and their aint nothin' you can do about it while IL'd, then FAR comes along and unless you have been keeping a careful eye on your surroundings (maybe I'm slow but I find it difficult to concentrate on all out of IL stuff while IL'ing someone) then you aren't gunna switch your hypers and tank up on ball def/res, so boom! you get hit with FAR and your health is non-existant, and that, quite un-simply, is why FAR needs to be IL only.


Jacked Out

Joined: Dec 27, 2006
Messages: 6256
Location: The Real World This is how MxO ends: Not with a bang but a whimper
Offline

AlphaCoder wrote:
FAR is a different story, but it really needs to be restricted to IL only, people are talking from the perspective of out of IL, if you are in IL and have someone shooting you with power tactic waiting for the staggered, they are more likely to state you and their aint nothin' you can do about it while IL'd, then FAR comes along and unless you have been keeping a careful eye on your surroundings (maybe I'm slow but I find it difficult to concentrate on all out of IL stuff while IL'ing someone) then you aren't gunna switch your hypers and tank up on ball def/res, so boom! you get hit with FAR and your health is non-existant, and that, quite un-simply, is why FAR needs to be IL only.

To be honest, I can't see why most of the gunmen moves (from a realism standpoint) can't be done OoIL. Those that require the user to be IL'd are those that make physical contact with the opponant.

To me it seems crazy to restrict a probably the only high powered, non-physical IL and OoIL move to IL only in a class which, for the most part, is supposed to be a both in and out of IL class, especially when it's long casting timer and poor accuracy plays a large factor even with high accuracy set of clothing. As for being in IL, if you're in IL with, for example, a MA and you have HyperBlock activated, you're just as screwed if a hacker comes along with logic cannon as you are with a gunner and FAR.

As for PRCS, I'd agree on a slightly longer reuse time and have the chance very high. Besides, technically it shouldn't say "100% chance of powerless (duration)". 100% means everytime, so it should say "causes powerless (duration). SMILEY


Message edited by Croesis on 06/16/2008 06:30:16.


Veteran Operator

Joined: Sep 19, 2007
Messages: 116
Offline

This post has moved:

/mxo/posts/preList.m?topic_id=36300..._id=36300468082

Spam.


Vindicator

Joined: Aug 21, 2006
Messages: 3158
Location: ALL YOUR AVATARS ARE BELONG TO ME
Offline

Vinia wrote:
AlphaCoder wrote:
FAR is a different story, but it really needs to be restricted to IL only, people are talking from the perspective of out of IL, if you are in IL and have someone shooting you with power tactic waiting for the staggered, they are more likely to state you and their aint nothin' you can do about it while IL'd, then FAR comes along and unless you have been keeping a careful eye on your surroundings (maybe I'm slow but I find it difficult to concentrate on all out of IL stuff while IL'ing someone) then you aren't gunna switch your hypers and tank up on ball def/res, so boom! you get hit with FAR and your health is non-existant, and that, quite un-simply, is why FAR needs to be IL only.

To be honest, I can't see why most of the gunmen moves (from a realism standpoint) can't be done OoIL. Those that require the user to be IL'd are those that make physical contact with the opponant.

To me it seems crazy to restrict a probably the only high powered, non-physical IL and OoIL move to IL only in a class which, for the most part, is supposed to be a both in and out of IL class, especially when it's long casting timer and poor accuracy plays a large factor even with high accuracy set of clothing. As for being in IL, if you're in IL with, for example, a MA and you have HyperBlock activated, you're just as screwed if a hacker comes along with logic cannon as you are with a gunner and FAR.

As for PRCS, I'd agree on a slightly longer reuse time and have the chance very high. Besides, technically it shouldn't say "100% chance of powerless (duration)". 100% means everytime, so it should say "causes powerless (duration). SMILEY<img src=" width="15" height="15" />

I'd like to see you dual pistol execution somebody 19 meters away, from a realism standpoint.



Jacked Out

Joined: Dec 27, 2006
Messages: 6256
Location: The Real World This is how MxO ends: Not with a bang but a whimper
Offline

No, you're right. DPE should be an IL only move, the animation for it OoIL uses only one pistol and the nature of the execution is meant to be close up. Whilst not physically touching the opponant I'd still say that it's more physical than some moves.


Vindicator

Joined: Aug 21, 2006
Messages: 3158
Location: ALL YOUR AVATARS ARE BELONG TO ME
Offline

So, I was PvPing, and it seems like pretty much every MA I fight that has some of Aikido loaded like LittleLeeLoo likes to PRCS on the first turn of interlock. And then if they don't die instantly, like to Maki-Okatashi and then PRCS as soon as possible afterwards.

but guise accordin to dis thred tat dusn't happan.

So my point still stands, and I guess Pylat isn't ever going to respond again so why exactly does (if we compare the other high level moves that are in the same place as PRCS, which concordantly have similar effects) PRCS get a 100% chance as opposed to the 30% of Suicidal and the just random as we know it percentage that the Wrist Throw (although as we've established, insane IS cost) has to stun? PRCS has the highest interlock accuracy of all three. Like normal, the Aikido tree has relatively low damage, self-buffs, and high defense rolls with their abilities. PRCS is a low damage, high rolling attack, that apparently gets a 100% effect chance rather than the other two in the other MA trees. Why is that? Yes, Powerless isn't as good as maybe stun, and Confusion is basically just another powerless, but I definitely do not think that the ability deserves a guaranteed 100% chance to cause it's powerless effect. If anything, the re-use timer should be boosted to 12 seconds, making it in theory unable to be used until 3 rounds later, but I don't want to nerf Aikido, I don't want people to never use Aikido because they can't use a *CENSORED* ability do the nerf'd interlock re-use timers. I just want a non-state ability that can be used in interlock as a regular move to be balanced like all the other effect interlock moves out there that DO NOT CAUSE THEIR POSSIBLE EFFECT 100% OF THE TIME. Is that so much to ask?


Message edited by Ballak on 06/16/2008 19:14:01.



Systemic Anomaly

Joined: Aug 21, 2005
Messages: 1011
Location: The Source
Online

MA needs a nerf




Virulent Mind

Joined: Apr 13, 2007
Messages: 801
Offline

Ballak wrote:

So, I was PvPing, and it seems like pretty much every MA I fight that has some of Aikido loaded like LittleLeeLoo likes to PRCS on the first turn of interlock. And then if they don't die instantly, like to Maki-Okatashi and then PRCS as soon as possible afterwards.

But, guys, according to this thread that doesn't happen.

So my point still stands, and I guess Pylat isn't ever going to respond again so why exactly does (if we compare the other high level moves that are in the same place as PRCS, which concordantly have similar effects) PRCS get a 100% chance as opposed to the 30% of Suicidal and the just random as we know it percentage that the Wrist Throw (although as we've established, insane IS cost) has to stun? PRCS has the highest interlock accuracy of all three. Like normal, the Aikido tree has relatively low damage, self-buffs, and high defense rolls with their abilities. PRCS is a low damage, high rolling attack, that apparently gets a 100% effect chance rather than the other two in the other MA trees. Why is that? Yes, Powerless isn't as good as maybe stun, and Confusion is basically just another powerless, but I definitely do not think that the ability deserves a guaranteed 100% chance to cause it's powerless effect. If anything, the re-use timer should be boosted to 12 seconds, making it in theory unable to be used until 3 rounds later, but I don't want to nerf Aikido, I don't want people to never use Aikido because they can't use a *CENSORED* ability due to the nerf'd interlock re-use timers. I just want a non-state ability that can be used in interlock as a regular move to be balanced like all the other effect interlock moves out there that do not cause their possible effect 100% of the time. Is that so much to ask?


Fixed.

jl10899 wrote:

MA needs a nerf


You're joking, right?


 
The Matrix Online » Top » Development Discussion » Development Roundtable Go to Page: Previous  1 , 2 , 3 , 4  Next
Go to:   

Version 2.2.7.43